“I think it’s my hip.” We hear this a lot at Complete City Health, and sometimes it is. But just as often, the hip turns out to be innocent and the real source is sitting a few centimetres higher, in the lower back.
It’s an easy mix-up to make. The hip and lower spine sit right next door to each other, share a lot of the same muscles, and are wired up by many of the same nerves. So when something is irritated in one, it can feel like it’s coming from the other. Here’s how to start telling them apart, and why getting it right matters.
Why Your Back Can “Pretend” to Be Your Hip
The nerves that leave your lower spine (around the L3, L4 and L5 levels) travel out to the buttock, the side of the hip, the groin and the front and outside of the thigh. If a disc in that area bulges or loses height, it can press on or irritate one of those nerve roots.
Your brain doesn’t always know exactly where the trouble started. It simply registers pain along the path that nerve supplies, which is very often right around the hip. This is called referred pain, and it’s why so many people end up stretching their hip flexors for months without much change.
For Sydney CBD office workers, the setup is common: long hours sitting, a commute spent in the same position, and very little movement to keep the lumbar discs healthy and nourished. Over time that steady load adds up.
Clues It Might Be Coming From Your Back
No single sign is definitive, but these patterns point toward the lower spine:
The pain moves around. One day it’s the buttock, the next it’s the side of the thigh.
It’s worse after sitting. Getting up from your desk or out of the car is the hardest part.
There’s nerve-type sensation. Tingling, pins and needles, numbness or a burning feeling running down the leg.
Bending, coughing or sneezing makes it flare. These all briefly increase pressure inside the discs.
Your back feels stiff too. Even if the hip is the loudest complaint, the lower back is quietly tight in the background.
Clues It Might Be the Hip Itself
True hip joint problems tend to behave a little differently:
Pain sits deep in the groin rather than the buttock or back.
It catches with walking, stairs, or getting in and out of the car, movements that load the joint directly.
Turning the leg inwards or crossing it over the other knee is uncomfortable.
Putting on socks and shoes becomes surprisingly tricky.
Of course, it’s possible to have a bit of both, and that’s exactly why a proper assessment beats guesswork.
Why Getting the Source Right Matters
If the pain is coming from your back, treating only the hip won’t get you very far. You might get short-term relief from stretching or massage, but the disc or nerve driving the symptoms is still under pressure, so the pain keeps coming back.
At your assessment, we look at how your hip and lower back move, test the nerves, check your reflexes and strength, and look for the patterns above. If imaging would help clarify things, we’ll talk you through that too. And if anything suggests the issue is better suited to another health professional, we’ll point you in the right direction.
When a compressed or irritated lumbar disc is the culprit, spinal decompression can be a really helpful part of care. By gently and gradually unloading the spine, it reduces pressure on the disc and creates a little more room for the irritated nerve to calm down. It often works best alongside movement, strengthening and practical changes to how you sit and work.
When to Seek Help Sooner
Please don’t wait if you notice weakness in your leg, numbness in the groin or inner thighs, changes to bladder or bowel control, or pain after a fall or accident. These need prompt medical attention.
Let’s Find Out What’s Really Going On
If you’ve been stretching, foam rolling and resting your “hip” with little to show for it, it might be time to look a bit higher up. Our team at Complete City Health in the Sydney CBD will take the time to work out where your pain is really coming from, and build a plan that actually targets it.